When it was announced Netflix was adapting Doerr’s “All The Light We Cannot See,” literary and film enthusiasts alike were alight with anticipation. But as the series unfolded on our screens this November, it became apparent that this adaptation was not content to merely retell. It sought to reimagine.
Before Reading: Spoiler-Free Series Night
If you’re keen to experience “All The Light We Cannot See” in its new, vibrant Netflix incarnation before delving into the depths of analysis, why not make an event of it? Organizing a series night could be the perfect way to immerse yourself in this story’s beautifully reimagined world, spoiler-free. Here’s how you can create an unforgettable viewing experience!
Set the Ambience
The ambiance is key to a good series night. Dim the lights — emulating the soft glow of a European village under the stars — and perhaps light a few candles, ensuring they’re safely placed. This will enhance the visual experience and subtly pay homage to the novel’s exploration of light and shadow.
If you have a surround sound setup, now’s the time to use it. If not, a quality soundbar or even a set of strategically placed speakers can greatly enhance the auditory experience. This will help you to draw deeper into the world of Marie-Laure and Werner.
Comfort is Key
Your viewing area must be as comfortable as possible. Fluffy cushions, cozy blankets, and comfortable seating can make the hours you spend in front of the screen feel like a luxury rather than a marathon.
Thematic Snacks and Drinks
Thematic treats can elevate your series night. French pastries, pretzels reminiscent of Werner’s German heritage, and a selection of cheeses could serve as nods to the settings of the series. For drinks, French wine or German beer could add an authentic touch, while non-alcoholic options like hot chocolate or CBD gummies (view more about those here) can be equally delightful.
Since “All The Light We Cannot See” is a series with multiple episodes, plan for intermissions. Brief breaks between episodes can help you discuss initial impressions and theories, or simply stretch and refresh before the next chapter begins.
A Social Affair (or a Solo Venture)
Decide whether this will be a solitary journey or a shared adventure. A series like this can be deeply affecting, and whether you wish to go through these emotions with friends or alone is a personal choice. If you do invite others, consider a post-viewing discussion session to unpack the series’ rich tapestry of themes.
Lastly, be mindful that “All The Light We Cannot See” touches on the tragedies of war and can be quite evocative. Prepare yourself and your guests for a narrative that may stir deep emotions, and allow space for everyone’s reactions and responses.
Series Review (With Spoilers!)
Madame Manec’s Evolution
Transforming Madame Manec from Etienne’s housekeeper to his sister was a bold choice that reconfigured familial bonds and motivations within the narrative. While I cherished the warmth of the original relationship, there was something profoundly moving about this new dynamic, especially as it nudged Etienne into the resistance’s heart. This change, though startling at first, carved out a deeper niche for Etienne in the story that I found surprisingly poignant.
The Shift to a Grittier Reality
The Netflix series takes a path soaked in more violence than the book’s pages, particularly in Werner’s arc. It was a jarring pivot from the novel’s internalized warfare, leaving me with mixed feelings. On one hand, the intensity of these scenes was gripping, but part of me longed for the novel’s quieter, more introspective moments that shed light on Werner’s internal moral dilemmas.
Hugh Laurie’s Etienne, who now occupies a more substantial role in the resistance and in Marie’s life, was a gamble that paid off in the emotional resonance department. His on-screen demise, however, was a departure I wrestled with. The novel’s Etienne had a subtler influence, and the amplification of his role was both a triumph and a tragedy that reshaped the series’ emotional landscape in a way the book never intended.
A Simplified Mystery
The Sea of Flames subplot, with its reduced complexity, was a double-edged sword. While I understood the need for streamlining, the simplification stripped away some of the original plot’s allure and intricacies that I found enchanting. Marie’s discovery of the gem, now less encumbered by deception, lost a bit of its narrative sparkle, yet it gained clarity that some viewers may find refreshing.
Werner’s Backstory and the Path Not Taken
Removing the touching friendship between Werner and Frederick erases a profound element of the story in my view. This absence was felt deeply, as it diminished the exploration of the emotional toll of war. While the series carved out its own narrative space, this particular omission felt like a missed opportunity to delve into the nuances of Werner’s character development.
The Dilemma of Closure
Netflix’s reinterpretation of the characters’ fates — particularly Werner’s — presents a starkly different endgame. The choice to offer a glimmer of hope in place of the novel’s more definitive conclusions was as bold as it was controversial. I found myself divided. The writer in me appreciated the poetic justice of the novel’s endings, but the optimist in me welcomed the possibility of a brighter future for Werner and Marie.
The Epilogue That Faded Away
The series’ decision to omit the epilogue was, for me, the most poignant loss. Doerr’s leap into the future offered a sense of closure that rounded out the characters’ arcs, a denouement that I missed while watching the series. This absence left me yearning for the novel’s closure and the fullness of the journey it provided.
Between Adaptation and Reinterpretation
Netflix’s “All The Light We Cannot See” serves as a reminder that adaptations can evolve into their own entities. This series, for all its departures, invited me to experience Doerr’s narrative through a new lens. And while I found myself at times longing for the untouched corners of the original story, I also found joy in the unexpected turns of this retelling.